You have written a great story. It is clean, as all the important bits, your test readers love it. You get a good cover, do research on categories and tags and search -optimization, and hit “PUBLISH!”

And get a flock of very low ratings, a few returns, and everyone claims that you are selling broccoli in a heart-shaped box. Or fancy chocolates in a package labeled “Steak.” What went wrong? You have all the necessary elements for the genre you market for, so why are readers fuming about false expectations and deceptive blurbs and covers?

Guess what. The tropes and beats that you saw as the most important are not what readers are seeing. Oops. You are trying to tell a detective story that has romance in it. What you are advertising is a romance that happens to involve solving a crime. Or vice versa. Both happen, like the highly lauded book a few years ago that was sold as “space opera” when it was political intrigue in space. No starships, no exploding planets, no heroic colonizers saving determined young women from BEM*s … Nope, it was about an ambassador to the court of a galactic empire, and what he did and observed there. The author and his publisher heralded this as a new style of space opera, one that expanded and elevated the genre away from Doc Smith, C. L. Moore, Norton’s Beastmaster, and David Weber to a more refined and genteel and intellectual status. Space opera fans ignored it in droves. People who like politics with a light coating of sci-fi didn’t want to touch rocket ships and lasers and BEMs.

Flop.

So, which are the strongest tropes in your work? If you were to look at Wolf of the World, it has many of the elements of Paranormal Romance. A strong female protagonist, a male lead who is [supernatural thing here], a bad guy who is also a [supernatural thing], and romance beats. The setting is the Carpathian Mountains, the season is spring/summer, and the guy and the gal are attracted to each other. EXCEPT – there is no sex, and the woman really is a strong female protagonist (do not tick off a former NCAA Division 1 softball pitcher when there are nice throwable rocks around. Just do not.) There is no meet, disagree, part, contemplate, get together again pattern either, and that is a major element in most modern romances. Therefore, the pattern is stronger for an urban fantasy with a romance in it, than for a paranormal romance. I market it as urban fantasy. No shirtless guy or leather-clad gal on the cover, because those are signals (or were when it was first released) for PNR.

Romance is the genre best known for trope-attracted readers. They are very sensitive to missing elements and false-claims, and will close their wallets when they feel they have been cheated. Sci-fi readers are a little more forgiving, but you still need to make certain you are marketing and categorizing with some care.

My upcoming release is a bit of a challenge. It is historical fantasy, mostly (OK, I borrow heavily from the Bronze Age, but we’ll leave that aside). But it has elements of mystery in it as well, because as the story progresses, the protagonist has to figure out why things are not fixed when they are supposed to be. However, it is NOT a mystery by the standard definition. There is no romance in the modern sense. Intrigue? Yes, but not of the political or spy thriller sort. The description is going to have to carry a lot of weight, and be very, very clear that this is a dark and eerie book. It is not a happy fun cozy fantasy. Nor is it horror, or coming-of-age, although that one miiiiight fit. The protagonist has to accept responsibility and not run away from a situation, even though he can, and by his position in society, probably would (in the real world.)

https://writersinthestormblog.com/2026/06/three-ways-to-lose-a-romance-reader/

*Bug Eyed Monsters. See the covers of a lot of pulps for examples.

Home