Hi there. I understand most of you write.

And my question to you is: why?

It is not “why” in the sense of “are you nuts?” We are, goes without saying. As it goes without saying that we write because we have to.

The “why?” here is more “What do you want to achieve with it?” or “If you had your wildest dreams, what would you like to be seen as?”

Or in other words, are you looking for fame or fortune, or both or neither?

I’ll lay my cards on the table right here and now: What I wanted was to make some money, help my family or maybe even match Dan’s income so he could quit and do something else that he wanted to do. I did not want fame. I actually didn’t want fame with an explosive sort of not wanting. I didn’t think this through. But anyway…

Eh. You could say I’m close to achieving this. If everything goes well and I stop getting sick all the time. Maybe. And it’s only been close on to thirty years.

The one thing I didn’t want and don’t particularly care about is …. prestige. I never imagined, say, being studied in school. No, wait, I imagined it a couple of times and laughed so hard I almost choked.

Anyway, the reason I ask is this: it’s important, apparently, for how you write, but more importantly for how you TALK about writing. Because if you want to be known as literary and special, you need to curate what you say.

At least that’s my only explanation for continuously running into grown ass adults who say completely stupid stuff like, I swear I’m not making it up, though I don’t remember where I ran across it: “of course, genre literature is written in a simplistic style, without metaphors or imagery that challenges the reader, so it attracts a different type of reader than literary fiction.”

They are paid to say that, right? They’ll get kicked out of the literary club if they don’t say that, right? Like Margaret Atwood saying she didn’t write science fiction because she didn’t write aliens and… what was it? big breasted women? something like that, it betrays nothing but a complete inability to understand other people and a refusal to do so much as open a book in that despised “genre” thing.

Because guys: I read everything. I’ve read the documentation for machines I didn’t own in a language I was only marginally functional on when I was out of other reading material. But I don’t as a rule read “literary” fiction. Note “Literary fiction” (with no other genre) is its own genre, and yes, I’ve read one or two dozen of them. I read them because back in the day before KU and when I was broke, I read everything I could get for free or very cheap.

So I read one or two “literary” titles a month, usually because they were in the library sale or out on one of the “these books are free because we can’t sell them” shelves outside bookstores. And sometimes I borrowed them from the library because they were recommended on newspaper review (Hey, I grew up, okay?)

So, I read a lot of them. Why don’t I read them anymore? Is it because they’re too difficult for my poor, simplistic, genre-reading brain?

ARE YOU ACTUALLY AND FOR REAL KIDDING ME RIGHT NOW?

The fact is that SF and fantasy — and hoo boy, mystery — have writers who are all about the similes, the metaphors and the difficult language. If what you want is to get drunk on language (eh. Sometimes) there are writers to suit your needs. Heck, even my first series.

But me? I read all levels. I get kind of bored by something that is extremely simplistic, but I also get bored by things that seem to be ABOUT the language and nothing else.

Neither of those has anything to do with not liking so called “Serious” and “literary”. No, the reason I don’t read those is that they are by and large “stories about despicable people doing despicable things in a boring way.” I mean, I can read thrillers or mysteries about despicable people doing despicable things, because they’re interesting. What I have found about so called “literary” books is that they are “plausible” to the kind of nebbish people who adore them — most professors I think — which means they are about upper middle class people and their neuroses, or what upper middle class people think the lower classes are like.

B-O-R-I-N-G.

I figure the only reason people read those, much less talk about how much more they love them than genre is for social display. Which means that if that’s the path you want to take, you need to start practicing those mouth-noises early and often, and never ever ever hint that you have read one of those simplistic “genre-trash” books.

And you should practice telling lies about what is in the “genre” books.

Fortunately I don’t have those problems. All I want is to make enough money that Dan can retire and make his music and write HIS books for a change.

So, you see, I’m one of those trash genre writers, and all I have to do is write things people want to read. Which is hard but not that hard.

So you might decide what you want to happen with what you write, because I can’t decide for you.

Do you want to write things people enjoy?

Or do you want the accolades of the cogniscenti?

….. I can honestly say I want the first. Very, very badly.

Oh, yeah, and in proof of this, and since this is the year of finishing all the things I have this on pre-order:

Witch’s Daughter (Empires of Magic Book 2)

Some letters come from the living. Some come from the dead. This one comes with a formula that turns a rowboat into a miracle.

Seventeen-year-old Lord Michael Ainsling — youngest brother of the Duke of Darkwater, builder of mechanical marvels, survivor of fairyland — receives a letter from a man sixteen years dead. The inventor Tristram Blakley has not perished; he has been imprisoned by his own genius and begs the one mind in all of Avalon brilliant enough to understand his work to set him free. All Michael has to do is find seven missing brothers first and walk a magical path..

Fifteen-year-old Albinia Blakley has spent her whole life under her mother’s iron thumb — and her mother is a witch. The day Al finally escapes down a rope of knotted sheets, she lands in a world she doesn’t recognize, with no money, no magic kit, and no idea that the stranger who catches her is about to become her greatest ally.

Together, a girl with more secrets than she knows and a boy who builds machines that try to murder him must outwit a sorceress, navigate the treacherous courts of Fairyland, and unravel an enchantment years in the making — before a family is lost for good.

Witch’s Daughter is a gaslamp fantasy brimming with wit, warmth, and wonder, for readers who love their magic wrapped in velvet and their adventures served with morning tea.

39 responses to “Why do you Write?”

  1. I write the stories I like and can’t find in the wild. I publish and promote because it’s an interesting challenge my brain isn’t really wired for, kind of like sudoku. It feels good when someone I am not related to has nice things to say about my books (I mean, it feels nice when relatives say nice things about my books too, but in a different way.) It would feel nicer if this particular pasttime would pay for itself, but here we are.

    1. Me too. There are stories I want to read, and nobody else is writing them. When in doubt, write what you want to read. You’re probably not so weird that nobody else will like it. 🤣

  2. Miss Marple, in A Caribbean Mystery:

    “Modern novels. So difficult—all about such unpleasant people, doing such very odd things and not, apparently, even enjoying them.”

    1. Excellent! Though, given that I came here to post that exact quote, I guess I’m going to have to find another one:

      “Raymond West…is…supposed to be a brilliant novelist and has made quiet a name as a poet. His poems have no capital letters in them, which is, I believe, the essence of modernity. His books are about unpleasant people leading lives of surpassing dullness.”

      Christie understood the “literary” genre!

      1. Michael Morley Avatar
        Michael Morley

        I think literary novels are written to impress people who want to consider themselves literati. It wouldn’t shock me to discover that a goodly fraction of the people who praise literary novels and want you to think they have rarefied taste in literature and wouldn’t be caught dead reading genre fiction actually have bookshelves and Kindles filled with the “sub-literary” works of Colleen Hoover, Tom Clancy, and Alistair MacLean.

  3. Forgot to add: cool cover and blurb on Witch’s Daughter.

  4. As to being studied and copied … George Gershwin went to Paris in the hope of studying with the genuinely great composers and teachers living there. Every one of them turned him down. “If I teach you, you’ll become a second-rate Stravinsky. But you’re already a first-rate Gershwin.” A,first-rate Gershwin who was earning more than any of the people he wanted to learn from!

    1. Yes, that sounds like Igor Stravinsky, in rather the same mood where he mocked the critics who accused him of selling out by sketching his initials in the air intertwined, to form a dollar sign.

  5. I write because

    1. I enjoy writing. It is a pleasant way to spend time.
    2. I enjoy research. It is like solving puzzles, another thing I enjoy.
    3. People pay me to write.

    I am not one for idleness. I want to keep busy. And if people will give me money for spending time on two things I enjoy doing (writing and research), of course I will spend time on it.

    Yes the money isn’t great, but when added in to a pension, social security and investment income, I make more than the salary I was earning as an engineer. And once you have paid off the mortgage, are over 65 (at which point health insurance prices plummet) and the kids have grown, are through college, and on their ow, all of a sudden your expenses drop. I had to have a day job and write weekends and evenings back then, but now I can write full-time and still make enough to grow the bank balance.

    So I write.

  6. “stories about despicable people doing despicable things in a boring way.” 

    LOL! I avoid any book that has to pretentiously label itself “A Novel”. You mean, boring, stupid, and about nothing anyone with half a life cares about, right? I honestly pity anyone who is working or has gotten an MFA because I’m sure that this is the only kind of tripe they teach.

    As for me, I write to tell people’s stories. What I want is for people to read my stuff, enjoy it, and have it leave them thinking about life. As I often quote Maude from Harold and Maude, “I love people. They’re my species!”

    A couple of years ago, I tried to sum up my odd tastes in the post An Eccentric Life.

    1. Jane Meyerhofer Avatar
      Jane Meyerhofer

      I probably should just let this ride but… I called my first book, _Marguerite: A Novel with a Little Murder_. I had no idea what I was doing but, although it’s not a very good book, it is not a literary piece of dreariness. Full of typos, terrible cover, great introduction for me into learning what indie publishing was all about. No one has to read it (obviously! lol). No one is reading it. I leave it up to keep me humble.

      1. And, hey, you got me to look. Four 5-star reviews ain’t bad. I guess there’s something to be said for false modesty. 🙂

      2. I’d class that as playing with the trope.

        Sort of like the “and zombies” or “Vampire hunter” fanfic of classic stories/characters do.

    2. Michael Morley Avatar
      Michael Morley

      . . .  I write to tell people’s stories. What I want is for people to read my stuff, enjoy it, and have it leave them thinking about life. 

      Me too. It would be nice to be able to quit my day job and live on book royalties, but it’s not necessary.

  7. LOL! “A Novel with a Little Murder” is not the same as just “A Novel”. Like the heroine in a romance novel, a great writer does a delicate dance with both humility and arrogance. Just keep dancing!

    1. Jane Meyerhofer Avatar
      Jane Meyerhofer

      blushes…. I’d be ashamed eight years later to have so many typos in my latest effort. But if I never tried I would never improve.

      1. Grammarly is a life saver. SERIOUSLY.

  8. I write so my imagination doesn’t leak into the real world. I write because I love telling stories, and some people enjoy reading my stories. I write to answer “What if” questions, and it justifies research, which makes me better at Day Job, too.

    Now, if the plants and weeds will stop growing long enough for me to get back to writing the WIP … [glares in a yardward direction. A honeysuckle flashes the middle tendril in response as saplings yell rude things in pecan]

    1. I think many of us write SF for the same reason they say God created alcohol to prevent the Irish from taking over the world.

      I may have noted this before, but my wife was on a panel once about, “Where Do You Get Your Ideas”, and I think many people were relieved that my wife limited herself to writing.

      1. Jane Meyerhofer Avatar
        Jane Meyerhofer

        I went and read that essay and it is hilarious….

      2. Michael Morley Avatar
        Michael Morley

        I think it was Barry Longyear who answered the question “Where do you get your ideas?” by saying they came from Schenectady.

  9. Primarily I write because it’s the only way to get the voices in my head to shut up.

    I have these little fantasies about fame and fortune, though they’re probably better in my head than they would be in real life. I have this daydream about Steven Spielberg making a movie based on one of my stories, and I get so much money from it that I can afford to (anonymously) pay for all of the kids and Sunday School teachers at my church to go on some sort of bonding vacation.

    There’s zero chance of that fantasy happening, though, because I am not capable of—how did you put it, Sarah?—”curat[ing] what [I] say” in any kind of sensible way. I’ve got less chance of getting a bestseller than I do of winning the lottery.

    Though, I guess every book I put out there is like it’s own little lottery ticket, and maybe one day one of them will turn up a winner!

    1. Getting the voices out of my head is important as well. When I don’t get the voices out, I have to distract myself and that is not good when I need to do it at work or trying to “make a life for myself.”

  10. I write because I must.

  11. Well, you do have to be more careful with them metaphors when writing that fantastic stuff. ’cause, you know, the reader needs to know whether you’re talking fancy-like about how her face was candlewax mean kinda pale, or stating a fact ’bout the wizard’s working.

    I go on at length here:

    https://writingandreflections.substack.com/p/it-figures

  12. RAH didn’t fill the page with flowery words and pretentious posturing. He told the story. Just one minor reason the Credentialed Literati still hate him even though he’s been gone for 38 years.

    July 7 will be his 119th birthday!

    1. He did have smooth, well-turned prose and more convincing characters than alot of writers. I’ve run across a few writers (not here) who did a lot of beating their chests about “just telling the story” and then their sample on kindle had about the same level of craftsmanship as the duck tales fanfic I longhanded when I was twelve and a half. No thank you.

      1. Nowadays you really do need adequate prose regardless of genre.

  13. I write to chase the ideas out of my head. And then — fortune would be nice, and fame, for a writer — well, it’s hard to grow rich without it.

  14. I’d say it’s because nobody writes or wrote what I wanted to read, but that’s not completely true. I write, when I do, because too many of the stories I enjoy didn’t focus as much on the characters I liked and I wanted to see what I could do with them, or reasonable facsimiles thereof. Either in a setting like the original one or something else entirely.

  15. I write for two big reasons-

    1-I want to tell the stories that nobody else seems to be writing about. I admit that I sometimes have very niche tastes, but I can’t be that niche…

    Can I?

    (Is competence and a certain amount of not holding the idiot ball a bridge too far for general entertainment these days?)

    2-There are places I will never be. Things I will never be able to do. Times I will never have while in this flesh and blood.

    If I can live-even for a moment-vicariously through other lives, it’s time well spent trying to get the right phrasing done.

  16. I love storytelling, always have. Helps keep the brain sane-ish, too. But I honestly started writing seriously partly in desperation, stuck in a situation where I couldn’t get a job but needed at least a smidge of money coming in. I figured if I couldn’t find what I wanted to read on the shelf, maybe enough other people couldn’t either that they’d buy my books….

    Some do. Now I need to write more books!

  17. So my imaginary friends can meet more, interesting people. ^.^

  18. I no longer know why I write.

  19. To pin the ideas down before they mutate. Well, as they mutate. To keep them from changing even further.

    Or something. Beats staring at the TV all day?

Leave a reply to An Author In Charge Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Trending