Do those look more like SF or like Fantasy characters, above?

While a great cover may catch a reader’s eye for the first time, the real “first chance to make a splash” moment has its foundation in genre definition. If the potential reader isn’t looking at the right pile in the first place, he’ll never see your book.

So, a failure in genre definition can be (deservedly) somewhat fatal to reaching the right audience (or in provoking negative feedback, like this article, if I were mean enough to name the title/author). So, don’t do that!

The case in point today is the SFF super-genre, in particular the distinction between Science Fiction and Fantasy.

The world of Science Fiction includes anything not explicitly impossible based on what we (think we) know, even if its plausibility is highly speculative. If a SF character seems to have non-scientific powers, like witchcraft, we should be confident that there is a rational (i.e., scientific) explanation for them, even if the science is, um, “futuristic” (and made up on the spot). Speculation is allowed, even if contradiction of “the known” is not (unless “the known” is also to be cancelled/replaced).

The world of Fantasy is not so bounded. Anything within the logic of the story is permitted. Now, since worlds without coherence are difficult to navigate when telling a story, artificial rules are common in fantasy (pigs can fly, but only if they’re virgins). When we tell children stories about Neverland, the world of the story must make internal sense or the story has no dwelling place, but its relationship to the quotidian world is not necessarily relevant.

I have just tooth-grittingly read a work that was supposed to be SF (rocket ships, aliens, mercenaries) that failed the genre test rather drastically and, as in many such instances, it was an unnecessary failure — a trivial (if fatal) failure to look at his worldbuilding intelligently. Quick summary of relevant points: Our hero is abducted accidentally from contemporary Earth by sheep-stealing criminals (go with it…) and taken far far away. When intercepted by “the law”, the criminals no longer have directions for the location of Earth. This is a fundamental (deliberate) STORY problem (the local galactic civilization descends from Earth species and they don’t know where their place of origin is and desperately want to find it. But this becomes a READER problem because all the in-place locals present (to our hero and the reader) as human-form (and talking) earth animals, e.g., human sized felines, canines, more exotic originals, etc. (all looking for their long ago original home. (Not ideal, but let’s play along…)

Here’s the REAL problem: the felines we are presented are based on modern cats, the canines on modern dogs, and etc., for the more exotic specimens, not on some version of their own long and varied Earth-ancestral evolutionary originals. (And worse, these are not just modern “cats”, they are “cats” that resemble the results of human domestication.) We are suddenly thrust into the world of Fantasy, as if in a just-so-stories children’s book. You can’t present “Known Science with a Twist” in your story environment and ignore the “Known Science” part of it.

Now, I could see ways of making this premise consistent: (Earth has only been raided once, in recent times…(but when did the Galactic civilization start?) or only one of each species has been raided (specifically denied in-story). But, basically, there’s no saving a premise this unexamined. It violates the whole premise of SFF — the Known Science part of it. If you’re going to have Earth felines and canines as intelligent alien species, either they came that way (not true at evolutionary source) or they evolved post-abduction (not true in story world).

This was the first book in a series (Our hero becomes a mercenary and has adventures. The females of some of the species seem interested in him.) Imagine how many more of those series entry I’m likely to read. (…fool me once,…).

What egregious setups have you encountered that resulted in book-flinging for genre definitions?

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Trending