… I’m here to opine about The Nutcracker.

I realized recently that I’d never seen this classic Christmas story and set out to rectify that gap in my education. Thanks to the magic of YouTube, I was able to do so, and ended up watching a performance put on by the Ukrainian National Ballet a few years ago, with a Wikipedia article at my metaphorical elbow to explain the plot.

Let me tell you, that thing was trippy as heck. I’d vaguely known that the story is about a young girl who gets a magic nutcracker doll for Christmas, it turns into a prince, and they have some sweet- pun intended- adventures before she either returns home or wakes up and wonders if it was all a dream.

But that’s all I knew about the story. I’d forgotten about the Mouse King- and, sidebar, that guy’s performance was excellent. I kept expecting him to stumble because part of his costume included a gray cloak that kept tangling around his ankles, but he’s a professional athlete, and little details like that didn’t seem to impair him. He was also quite creepy, an excellent villain who was defeated halfway through the story. It made a good climatic moment for Act I, but there was still half the show to go, which puzzled me.

And there wasn’t an obvious climax to Act II, unless you count the moment Clara wakes up in her home and sees the nutcracker doll, which took about ten seconds in this performance. The story, just, sort of, ended. Very weird.

But it only ended after a variety of dances meant to symbolize coffee, tea, chocolate, and the other sweets that live in the fairy kingdom. Say what? Now I’m wondering if the idea for Candyland came from the same recesses of the human mind. And it’s funny to think that portal fiction has been around for so long; apparently, isekai isn’t a new trend, it’s a continuation of an old multi-national tradition.

The portrayal of Clara was also interesting- she’s supposed to be a young girl, specific age not given, but the prince who accompanies her on her adventures is very obviously a love interest. Those two things shouldn’t go together, and I’m sure lots of academics have spilled lots of ink discussing Victorian ideas of childhood and growing up and how they relate to Clara’s dream of an adulthood that includes a handsome prince and a kingdom populated by candy, and her subsequent awakening back in her childhood.

There’s a lot of room for variation in adaptations for the stage, and one other thing that made my write brain go, ‘hmm…’ was their portrayal of Drosselmeyer the magician. He was a very dark, seductive presence at the party in Act I, and I kept expecting him to show up as the Big Boss villain at the end- remember, my knowledge of the plot was vague, and the article I was using to follow the plot said there are a lot of variations on the original story. But Drosselmeyer never showed up again, and I was left scratching my head a bit.

Another trippy bit was the costumes. They were beautiful. But everyone was dressed in Georgian style- think American Revolution. Powdered wigs and knee breeches for the gentlemen, big wide skirts for the ladies. For a story that’s set in the 1820s, fifty years after the style shown on the stage. My best guess is that Georgian style looks more glamorous, and is also easier to dance in, so the costumer and director made A Choice.

My final assessment of The Nutcracker is: beautiful to look at, lovely music, very weird plot. I’m glad I filled this gap in my education, and maybe next year I’ll watch another performance of the story and compare it to this one.

Happy Boxing Day, all!

6 responses to “On the Second Day of Christmas”

  1. We have a treasured VHS tape of the Northwest Pacific Ballet version of The Nutcracker – the one where the set design and costumes were all derived from the Maurice Sendak illustrated version of the story.

    It really is a rather bizarre little story – but the music and that production itself were magnificent. I’m holding out for a dvd version, but so far, no luck.

  2. I tend to think of act 2 as a very protracted victory celebration, sort of like if Aragorn’s was the entire last section of Lord of the Rings, or the throne room with the medals in A New Hope was about the same length as the movie preceding it. The Mirror Mirror rendition of “I Believe in Love” is kind of the same thing, but of course much shorter than Nutcracker act 2.

  3. I find it unfortunate that the Nutcracker is usually the first ballet that kids see, and often the only one. Because, as you point out, story-wise, everything is in the first act. The second act has beautiful music, incredible dancing, and leaves a juvenile audience bored to tears. I suspect that it’s more responsible for putting people off ballet than even the worst stuff from high school English classes is for putting people off literature.

    The Nutcracker Suite makes for beautiful background music for a Christmas party, but performances of it are probably best left for connoisseurs of dance or classical music who can appreciate just watching a performance without needing a plot. For the kids, take them to…well, pretty much any other ballet would be a better choice, actually!

  4. I read an article in which it was posited that it was the first and practically the last ‘middle class’ ballet. Because Russia despite the Tzars was evolving a middle class due to the industrial revolution making its way to Russia in fits and starts. The ballet among other things celebrates all the cool stuff ‘middle class’ folks can enjoy like coffee and candy. As we know this period in history lasted about five minutes.

  5. I suspect one reason kids go to see Nutcracker is because other kids are in it (at least here.) It is relatively inexpensive to stage if the company already owns some of the sets or props, and the troupe can use the show to give students and junior members stage experience.

    The novella by E.T.A. Hoffman is darker and stranger than the ballet usually is. I’ve seen it end with Clara and the Prince getting married, because she ages when she enters his realm. Other versions leave the ending ambiguous, with Clara and the Prince still in his kingdom as the curtain falls.

  6. I’ve heard a version that ends with their marrying. Indeed, it ends with a little girl in her grandfather’s lap being told that they married, and had many children, and whenever they told their children to go to bed, they went right away.

Leave a reply to TXRed Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Trending