By Mark Lardas
My name is Mark Lardas. You know me on MadGeniusClub by my handle Seawriter. I am an author (trad press, usually), and I review books. A lot of books. I will write at least 75 400-word to 1000-word book reviews this year and possibly as many as 90. Plus 100 or so blurbs. I started reviewing books in 1996, and have written weekly reviews since 2006. Publications running my reviews include Galveston Daily News, Epoch Times, Nautical Research Journal, and Ad Aatra.
The previous paragraph was not to establish how wonderful I am. I wrote to demonstrate I know something about book reviews. I have been reviewing them a long time. I know what editors want from a review and how to maximize the chance of getting a review accepted and published.
Are reviews an effective marketing tool for an indie author? I do not know. I suspect so, but I just write reviews. I don’t know how they affect sales. Ask authors whose books I have reviewed. They know. On MGC that includes Sarah Hoyt, Dave Freer, and Cedar Sanderson.
I do believe getting a book reviewed helps get past the background noise of the publishing industry. A review in a major publication gives the reviewed book wide attention. Readers suddenly know about the book. Some buy it – which they cannot do if they have never heard of it.
How do you get your book reviewed? Or rather how do you maximize the chance of getting it reviewed? Here are guidelines:
- Find a reviewer. (You know one: me. I write 75-90 reviews a year and am always looking for a good read.) Ask author friends which reviewers they know and ask for an introduction. Go to major newspapers and magazines and search for the features editor. (Sometimes there is even a reviews editor.) Contact them and ask who reviews books for them and how to get them a review copy of your book. Consider putting your book up at Netgalley.com. (No, I don’t know how. I get a lot of books I review from their website, though.)
Don’t start with the New York City or Los Angeles publications. Try a local paper with some tie-in to your book. Local new authors are catnip to hometown papers. If the book features a location, contact publications near that location. Or look for organizations with an interest in your book. (NSS for science fiction for example)
- Get the reviewer a copy of your book. Do whatever you can to make it easy on the reviewer. Do they want it dead trees? Send a print version. Do they want it electronically? Send them the e-version. Better still, ask what format is desired (EPUB, MOBI, PDF, whatever). If possible, send that. Maybe you don’t have the desired format but do the best you can. Finally send it where they want it sent. Some reviewers work out of their homes. Others exclusively at the office. Ask where they prefer the book to be sent and send it there. (Either by post or electronically.)
- Have a print version. Often, this is an absolute must. Epoch Times will not let me review a book without a dead-trees version. (We experimented blurbing digital-only books but got firm pushback by review readers. Now it is forbidden.) Even if the intended audience is mainly digital have a printed version. (If you want to charge $2.99 for the e-book and $29.99 for the paperback, that works. Reviewing publications don’t care if the print price is unreasonable, just that is available.)
- Have a publishing house, even if it is your basement. A lot of editors will see “Independently Published,” and kill the review. Not always, but most times. It is a fight to get independently published books reviewed and I do not dare do it too often. Create your own imprint. Think Goldport Press or Wordfire Press. It checks an important box.
- List your book on Amazon. If you are not on Amazon a lot of publications will not review your book. Period. The Amazon URL is a requirement for every review I submit to most publications. It does not matter if you loath Amazon with the heat of 1000 suns. You must be listed on Amazon to get a review from anything other than your friend’s blog. Include a print version at Amazon.
- Don’t annoy the reviewer. Sending a query to confirm the reviewer got the review copy is fine and accepted as normal. Sending an e-mail every week asking when your book will be reviewed? Not so much. There are many reasons a review will be delayed or never appear. Stuff might be happening to the reviewer. An editor might have rejected the review. A better book might have bumped yours. (Yes. It happens. There might be better authors than you.) It does not fit. Or the reviewer might feel it better for everyone not to review the book.
- Answer reviewer questions quickly and politely. Getting a reviewer query about your book is a good thing (generally). It means the reviewer is invested enough in the book to have questions needing clarification. Send off a response as soon as you can, and do not get triggered. Respond civilly.
That is it. Questions? Put them in the comments. I’ll do my best to answer quickly and politely.
(Thank you, Seawriter, for the guest post. Very sorry to run it so late. Holly)



9 responses to “Getting Your Book Reviewed”
Seawriter,
Thanks for the tips. I haven’t tried to get my novel reviewed because I don’t believe most reviews actually boost sales much unless you’re already established. Of course I could be wrong, so I appreciate the advice. So far I’ve hit all of your must-haves except one. When I created the paperback version, I was confronted with the request for my publishing house. Being momentarily at a loss for creativity, I just used my own name. Seems I’ll have to remedy that. I guess it’s time to get my “little grey cells” working on that. 🙂
I might be wrong, but reviews are one way to get established. It is a way to get your name and your book in front of a lot of people who might otherwise never hear about you.
The biggest problem with indy publishing is getting past the noise of tens of thousands of other books being published independently. Getting a book reviewed is one way for an unknown to break that noise barrier. I’d be curious as to what those whom I have reviewed in the past might say about that.
I’m curious too. Always happy to collect information.
Thanks for this. I don’t have an ‘imprint’ either and my next book will have to go out without one. I’m too close to publishing to solve that one right now. The ideas of how to find a reviewer are interesting. I assume a reviewer should have some interest in the kind of book they are reviewing. I looked up some of your books once and thought my son would love them. I should probably go read some of your reviews as well.
I am probably unusual in that I am both a fast reader and an omnivorous reader. So I am interested in a lot of things besides what I write. Yes, I am interested in history, but I write history because I can sell those most easily to publishers. They are fun to write, too.
But, unless I am offered a significant payout or I really owe an editor a favor I don’t review books in fields that do not interest me. My philosophy is that a review for a general publication should be a recommendation – hey! This is worth a read. If I cannot write a positive review, I’ll find something else to review.
Oh, the memories!
My dear husband, Bill, used to write reviews for the Rock Hill Herald in Rock Hill, SC, for about 10 years (1992 – 2000). Back then, he got an entire page in the newspaper every Sunday to do with as he wished. He’d publish reviews from other Herald personnel, too. I remember that Misty Massy reviewed science-fiction and fantasy for him.
Despite the Herald being a smallish newspaper (90,000 circulation on Sunday back in the 90s when newspapers still mattered; now, it’s about 90% less than what it used to be), he received, free, pickup-truck loads of books from publishers big and small.
We donated the vast majority of the books to the York County library system. Were they glad to get new fiction for free!
We had ZERO idea of how far his reviews reached. The Herald sent them on via McClatchy’s news service so far more people than Rock Herald subscribers saw his reviews. But we don’t know.
That’s the thing about reviews. You don’t know how far or widespread they are. We also don’t know if his reviews sold books. Maybe? Simply because someone saw the review and realized the book was available?
Reviews can’t hurt.
Worth looking in to. My works are midlist at best, once they get the rust knocked off them. Most of my time is spent caring for older relatives outside of my public profile, which doesn’t want any attention other than official and proper stuff. Writing is cathartic, and something of a hobby to keep me out of trouble when I retire. Appreciate the info.
Mark, I’d love to talk to you about who you do reviews for, and send you some of our novels / boys books from Raconteur Press. What’s the best way to get in contact with you?
If you’d rather not make your contact info public, you can get in touch with me via “pr at raconteurpress dot com”.
I’ll get in touch.