by Amanda S. Green

Ten years ago today, they say the world changed. I’m not sure the whole world changed, but my piece of it did. For the first time in my life, I understood how my parents’ generation felt when they heard about the attack on Pearl Harbor. Gone was the sense of safety of living in the United States, secured by oceans on two sides and allies on the other two sides. We’d been attacked, not by a military force but by fanatics who didn’t care about the innocents they killed in an effort to make their statement.

I know some of you are wondering what this has to do with writing. After all, Mad Genius Club is a blog about writing and the publishing industry. There is no simple answer. But there are answers and I’ll try to explain.

There’s a thread that’s been going on in one of the email groups I belong to where someone asked if our writing is influenced by world events. You can imagine there were folks coming in on both sides – some saying yes and others saying no. For me, I have to admit that I really hadn’t given it much thought. I knew the events of 9/11 affected me, but I hadn’t really taken time to think about if they had influenced my writing.

I still didn’t think much about it until the list of free titles available from Amazon crossed my desk the other day. I didn’t know whether to be thrilled or appalled to see all of them that dealt with that horrible day. I truly believe we need to remember what happened that day and do all we can to make sure it never happens again – here or anywhere else. One way to do that is to write about it.

But what appalled me were the number of books that had clearly been written just to cash in on the ten year anniversary of that horrible day. We’re not talking books that have been out for months or years and are just now being made free as promotions. No, we’re talking books that have never been available before. Books I couldn’t bring myself to download.

Look, don’t get me wrong. I’m all for authors using events, real and imagined, in their books. But to use a tragedy like 9/11 or the Holocaust just to sell books is more than I can stomach. Releasing those books so close to the anniversary of that horrible day without thought or concern about what it would do to those who survived or those who lost loved ones makes my blood boil. There are some lines I simply can’t step over.

That said, I will fight for these authors’ right to publish such books, whether I like them or not. That freedom of speech is one of the things that makes this country what it is. Within certain very limited provisions, we can write what we want, when we want. The fact that so many of us have different views on what and how we write is in the best interest of the reader.

On 9/11, I slept in later than I usually do. As I stumbled into the kitchen for my first cup of coffee, I turned on the TV. There are three things I do every morning: drink coffee, read the paper and watch the morning news. So there I was, coffee cup in hand, staring in disbelief as the second jet crashed into the Twin Towers. It had to be a nightmare. There could be no other explanation. Numb, praying for those people who were obviously trapped in the towers, I sat and watched, just like so many others that morning.

The images from that day are indelibly etched into my memory. So are the emotions. The shock, the fear, the anger. But so is the feeling of solidarity, of needing to do something as I stood in line at the local blood bank waiting hour after hour to donate blood in case it was needed. Hundreds of people turned out that day, too many for the small center to handle. No one wanted to go home. This was something they could do. Something they had to do.

Those who were turned away made appointments to come back the next day. Then they left, only to return later with water and food for those of us still in line. A couple came back with radios and TVs so we could watch the latest. No one asked them to. Everyone thanked them. We were all pulling together and it was happening across the country.

The emotions I felt that day were so strong. So were the reactions of the people I saw. The only day that had come close to it was the day when the American embassy in Tehran had been taken over, beginning more than a year of nightly reports about what was happening, reports that became ABC’s Nightline. Back then, I was attending Texas Tech. A number of my classmates were former Air Force officers. As we sat in the break area of the law school after the news broke, each of them were doing what was necessary to make contact with their former C.O.’s, doing what they felt was necessary – offering to return to the service of their country.

As I write this post, I realize there is one thing about 9/11 that has influenced my writing. After feeling so deeply, after seeing others do the same, I became more aware of how my characters should feel and react. I hope I am able to write characters who are no longer cardboard cut-outs. Emotions are what make us human and are what drive us, for good or bad.

I’m not a subscriber to the idea that you have to suffer for your art. Hell, I do my best to avoid suffering – at least in the way it is used in that sentence. But to be a good writer, you have to not only know what the emotions are, you have to know what they feel like – whether you have experienced them yourself or know someone has. More than that, you have to be able to express those emotions in your writing in such a way your characters don’t appear to be cartoonish or cardboardish.

I remember the feeling of helplessness as I stood in line at the blood bank, wondering if my son was all right. He was at school that day. When the district announced parents could come get their kids, I called my ex-husband to see if he was going to pick our son up. (It was his week to have the kid) I wanted to go so badly, just to be able to see for myself that my son was all right. I wanted to be the one to explain to him what had happened and to reassure him that I would do everything in my power to make sure nothing happened to him. I might not have been able to pick him up – my ex did that – but I did get to talk to him afterwards, to explain what happened and what might be happening over the next few days and weeks.

I can channel those emotions into my characters. It’s easier to write about the mother whose child is in danger. I understand the fear and anger and the need to protect. I can write about the everyman who feels helpless as he watches some disaster – be it natural or manmade – unfold before him. It is up to me now to hone my craft so I can write it in a believable way.

But for all of that, 9/11 reminded me of something I hadn’t really forgotten but had, like so many others, taken for granted. It reminded me of how much I love this country. I honor and thank those who willing put their lives on the line every day to protect it, be they police officers, firefighters, EMTs, soldiers, whatever. I thank their families for supporting them. Most of all, I thank God for the fact that I live here, in a country where I can write what I want and not have to look over my shoulder in fear that the thought police will be there to arrest me.

That son I worried so much about ten years ago is now a young man. One year ago today he signed his contract with the Air Force. It was his choice and one I am very proud of. It’s also one that can’t help but scare me some as well. And that is yet another emotion I can channel, if I dare.

In closing, and on a very non-writer note, I offer up a prayer for all of those who lost their lives a decade ago and I pray we never again see another 9/11, here or anywhere else.

12 responses to “Ten Years Later”

  1. The memorial celebrations are on all the news stations tonight. Of course it is evening here and morning where you are in the US.

    Ten years ago my youngest son was in grade one. He’s grown up in a very different world from the one I grew up in.

    1. Rowena, I know what you mean. However, at least here, the only difference is that we have another generation or two that realizes we aren’t absolutely secure. It’s a lesson our parents learned with Pearl Harbor. It’s one we forgot. I have my guesses as to why, but that would go so far into politics I won’t go into it. But, yes, are kids are more aware of the fact that no one can be truly safe when fanatics decide they need to make a strike against “the enemy”.

  2. Amen. I remember logging in to the Bar that day, just to be -as much as possible, with my friends there.

    1. Dave, I hadn’t joined the Bar back then. But I remember reaching out to family and friends as well, anything to make sure at least that part of my life was still there.

    2. Dan was in Washington DC, in a secure conference room which MIGHT have been in the pentagon. I didn’t know. And his cell phone wouldn’t pick up, and I didn’t hear from him for two hours. He didn’t get home — driving alone cross country — for three days. That day made us decide he’d quit his travelling job, even for one with much less pay. We don’t regret it, but I remember the iNFURIATING sense of helplessness that day. I swore an oath similar to the military when I naturalized. And I could do nohting.

  3. That day taught me an emotion — impotent rage. My submarine was in the shipyard for overhaul. It had a half-dozen huge holes in the hull to support the maintenance. The men and women I had sworn to defend were dying, before my eyes, and my shipmates and I couldn’t do ANYTHING to save them.

    I think that world events can’t help but shape what we write, whether we’re consciously aware of that influence or not. Because the entire culture changes, and there are very few of us who are capable of stepping completely outside of that setting and looking back at it. Even small things, like the invention of the cell phone. People (like my kids) who live immersed in today’s tech can’t comprehend how things were in my childhood, when my three-mile walks along our little two-lane country road put me as completely out of touch with the rest of humanity as I would have been in space. That shared knowledge of being not-connected is gone, and a writer would have to work harder to explain it.

    1. Steve, I can’t begin to imagine how you and your shipmates must have felt. I know the firefighters, EMTs and cops I knew then talked about feeling the same way. They were ready to walk away from their jobs — once it became clear nothing was going to happen in our part of the country — and drive straight through to NYC and Shanksville and Arlington, VA. They wanted to be there to support their brothers and sisters in uniform and I hurt for them because they couldn’t.

  4. And in the meantime we have put a 9/11 memorial on Mars–the planet Mars:

    http://www.jpl.nasa.gov/news/news.cfm?release=2011-281

    1. To which I can only say, good!

  5. Japan has had a surfeit of shows this weekend, reminding us of 10 years since 9/11 and 6 months since 3/11/2011 (The Tohoku Earthquake and Tsunami). The juxtaposition… I keep thinking of the old Zen story, of the samurai who asked a Zen priest to explain heaven and hell to him. The priest looked at him and said, “You fool!” The samurai started to pull his sword, furious. The priest said, “Now you see hell.” The samurai jerked to a stop, pushed his sword back into its sheath, and bowed to the priest, who said, “And now you see heaven.”

  6. […] Ten Years Later (madgeniusclub.com) […]

  7. Very well said, all the way around, Amanda.

    As for me on 9/11, I did much the same as you. I turned on the news and saw the planes crashing into the Twin Towers. I felt terrible; I was living in Council Bluffs, Iowa, and there wasn’t anything I could possibly do to help anyone. I was very worried about my friends and family stationed around the world; more to the point, as a former military wife I worried about *every* soldier and *every* soldier’s wife or husband, as war seemed imminent and even a just war for a just cause, as it seemed likely then, is brutal for all concerned.

    I remember the lines to donate blood (I wasn’t able to do that; I do think I brought some food to some of the others after I was told I couldn’t do so). I remember talking to my friends on the Bar and off. I remember talking with my father and mother long-distance. All were good things.

    But the feeling of absolute and utter helplessness was the dominant one; that, and shock. I couldn’t believe anyone would ever want to do something like that, much less a well-coordinated attack. (I think the USA lost our collective innocence regarding terrorism that day. I don’t know about you, but while I’m glad to have more knowledge about such terrible people as Al-Qaeda and the unlamented Osama bin Laden, I wish to have that innocence back if it meant that people overall had evolved beyond the need to do anything like this. I hope this makes some sense.)

    That anyone can sell books based off this 10th anniversary is sickening, especially considering all the complicated feelings that tend to come up when someone asks, “Where were you on 9/11?”

    Anyway, that’s what comes up after reading and thinking about your well-written, coherent post. Thank you for writing this, Amanda.

Trending