Recently, I have walled more books than usual. Proverbially, that is, since I don’t have funds in the kitty for replacing sheetrock after an e-reader hits it*. Usually it is nonfiction that causes me to close the book and return it to the library ASAP, or remove it from my e-reader. However, recently it has been fiction.

Without naming names, here are some things that threw me out of the book, and the book off my e-reader. They are all fiction. Nonfiction generally gets walled because of overly-modern opining, or major factual errors.

Book One started with technical descriptions of the characters, their armor in various modes, their weapons, and then a lot of background information. I do not want to get thirty pages of appendix or world building before reaching the actual story. Work it into the text, please, or have a technical appendix for those so inclined. If Tolkien can do it, we later writers can do the same.

Book two gave the character special power because of being a member of a knightly order affiliated with a religion. Then the author turned around and said, in essence, “Nah, it’s not belief in a deity, it’s belief in yourself. The deity thing was just a set up for what needs to be done. Trust yourself, and you can do the thing.” And lo and behold, the MC could do the thing. Ah, no. That might be OK for most people who read that genre, and it could be a genre convention in some urban fantasy, but that broke the book for me. I read a little farther and quit. Since the book had been sold in a way that seemed faith-positive, it was a double letdown. (Might be what I brought to reading the sales copy and excerpt, so this one could be more Alma problem than author problem.)

Book Three was page after page of text message, broken with a few descriptive paragraphs, then more texting. It was supposed to be an adventure story, not an epistolary novel. Bye-bye.

What else will lead to book meeting wall? What is supposed to be a romantic fling that suddenly becomes non-consensual, then is consensual because of [guilt/fate/species protection]. That threw me out of the entire dang series. I slammed the book shut, got my car keys and license, and drove the book back to the library. Yes, it fell within the “fated mates” trope, but oh heck no, absolutely not. I refuse to read things that make me feel soiled.

Too many pages of naval gazing by the protagonist, agonizing over things instead of: doing things, or talking to other people, or just going outside and breathing the air and touching grass (or gravel, or a sidewalk, or the sky.) It was billed as cozy fantasy, and the description sounded like cozy fantasy, so it might have been “wrong book uploaded.” Or it might have been right book, but wrong sales tack for a US audience. That one also went back to the library.

Another way to toss me out of a book is to get the geography completely wrong. When the tension in your opening scene depends on the Alps running north-south … You lost my faith. How bad are other things in the story? Did he think a halberd was a kind of fish? Confuse rapiers, broadswords, and shields? [A targe as used in Scotland is NOT an edged weapon that goes back into a sheath after a battle. Do your research.]

Some of these gripes are personal, and wouldn’t be offputting to other people. Some are me being old [get off my cemetery plot, whippersnapper!] and preferring to read dialogue and embedded things rather than page after page of text messages. Some are flat out bad formatting. Put the technical things in the back, unless 1) you are David Weber and I can skip the cast list, 2) need to fill readers in about something [pronunciations, genre warnings and cues], or 3) need to recap through a timeline or quick note information readers might need.

Have you walled anything recently? What tosses you out of a book, or causes you to toss the book, or is the oddest reason to toss the book that you have encountered?

*I just had a dying tree removed and a young tree put in. Alas that I do not have a wood burning stove, because that was a lot of “free” firewood that trundled off with the arborists.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Trending